Thor: The Dark World

Thor The Dark World

  • Rife with narrative flaws and failing to transcend genre, Thor: The Dark World is nonetheless fun, escapist entertainment.
  • Jane (Natalie Portman) still doesn’t convince she’s an academic, her ability to label Asgardian technology and manipulate Erik Selvig’s (Stellan Starsgaard) odd rods notwithstanding. The screenplay doesn’t bother to define Jane as more than a pretty damsel pining for Thor, so we don’t feel the weight of her intellect or independence.
  • Which causes Jane’s participation in the finale, indeed in most of the plot, to feel forced, perhaps even more than in the first film.
  • Similarly, Malekith (Christopher Eccleston) is one of the worst superhero villains I can remember seeing. Ever. We don’t understand what he’s doing, really, and we have no concept of his motivation.
  • Which is why he feels like a plot device, not a character. He’s an excuse to free Loki, but since his plot is The Dark World’s core, the movie suffers from his poor development.
  • Despite Tom Hiddleston’s best efforts. Yes, Loki is the best character in the Thor franchise, but Hiddleston’s performance matches the role. Without him, The Dark World might be an unabashed failure.
  • The Dark World is . . . well . . . often dark. And its darkness might have allowed it to transcend the super hero genre, might have made us feel for its characters, especially after Frigga (Rene Russo) and Loki interact with Malekith or his minions. Such events might have been deeply emotional, but they aren’t, at least in part because Director Alan Taylor doesn’t let his characters respond emotionally. Instead, he rushes to ever more Malekith-driven action sequences, seemingly never realizing that Malekith is not interesting.
  • Thor’s family, however, is, meaning The Dark World would have been better if Malekith had been its subplot and the Asgardian family drama its core.
  • The Dark World is heavy on exposition, especially in its slow-moving first act, but it still doesn’t explain many key plot points, a fact that makes the narrative downright silly at times.
  • Yet, for all of its missteps, Thor: The Dark World remains entertaining, in no small part because Loki, Selvig, Darcy (Kat Dennings) and Richard (Chris O’Dowd) give it a comedic tone.
  • Also, the action sequences are riveting, and Chris Hemsworth’s titular performance is as charismatic as ever.
  • The ways in which the art departments differentiate the nine realms makes for an interesting visual display. Ditto that for the film’s climax.
  • Thor: The Dark World is not great movie-making; it is much too flawed for that. But it is funny and entertaining, facts that keep it afloat despite its mistakes.
  • Final Grade: C+

12 thoughts on “Thor: The Dark World

  1. Sorry to hear you didn’t enjoy this one as much as I did! I do agree with you on several things–particularly Jane being kind of lame and Malekith being a sub-par villain–but I guess I just had too much fun to let the bad get to me. 🙂 Nice review!

    • Thank you.

      And I had a ton of fun, too, actually. The fun is why I gave it an above average grade. If it hadn’t been so entertaining, it would have received no better than a C-, because the narrative flaws are fairly extreme.

  2. Very fair review, I’d have to agree with all of it. Well, except for the fact that I was deeply, deeply irked by Darcy in this go-around. Her and the other intern ruined every single scene they were in. . . I understand that Thor does rely on a relaxed atmosphere, because after all this epic demi-god thing would seem a little too pretentious (dare I say, high brow?) otherwise, so the humor is appreciated. But these two overdo it completely. Still, a good bit of fun to be had every now and then.

    • I can see why you’d say that about Darcy and (what was his name?) Ian. They are over the top.

      Had they been given additional screen time, they would have bothered me, too. We just see little enough of them that they don’t.

      (Though. SPOILER ALERT: What was up with Ian flipping a car over at the end? Am I supposed to think he has some gifts of his own? I hope not.)

  3. I liked this one – quite a bit : ) I know it had problems – like that scene with the cell phone – but I thought it was mindless good fun : )

  4. The story doesn’t get started until Loki is broken out of jail halfway through. Thor was reduced to being a supporting part in his own film. Agreed that “Loki is the best character…” In this entry anyway.

  5. Sorry you didn’t like it that much, but you make a lot of fair points. Alan Taylor’s input really shines here, bringing his Game of Throne’s style with him. The action sequences and sets are remarkable, especially the film’s last act between Thor and Malekith.

    Nice review!

    • Agreed on the action sequences between Malekith and Thor.

      It’s not that I didn’t like it (I did – it’s fun and entertaining); it’s that I think it flawed.

      I grade with a Bell Curve in mind, so a C is average, a C+ is still above average. I also recommend anything with a C+ or better grade.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s